Menu Close

Supreme Court allows case against U.S. for causing toxic waste pollution in Guam (Mariana Islands)

The US Supreme Court ruled Monday in Guam v. United States that a case against the US for causing toxic waste pollution in Guam may proceed.

This case originated from a lawsuit by Guam against the US accusing the Navy of causing the contamination at the Ordot Dump. Guam alleged that the US was responsible for the costs of closing and remediating the landfill under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA).

The Ordot Dump was built and operated by the Navy in the 1940s as a site for disposing of municipal and military waste. Guam alleges that this waste included munitions and chemicals such as DDT and Agent Orange for decades without environmental safeguards. The contaminants leaked into the Lonfit River and ultimately flowed into the Pacific Ocean.

In the early 2000s, the US Environmental Protection Agency sued Guam under the Clean Water Act to gain a court order compelling Guam to address the dump. Guam subsequently paid a civil penalty, closed the dump, and created a cover system. The dump was closed in 2011, and Guam initiated its lawsuit against the US in 2017.

The Supreme Court unanimously ruled in favor of Guam. The Navy had argued that Guam was responsible for the costs because it took “response actions,” which, under CECLA, would trigger the statute of limitations to toll. If the statute of limitations began to run, it would be more than six years passed, thus making it too late for Guam to bring this claim.

The court disagreed: “[R]elying on that functional overlap to reinterpret the phrase ‘resolved its liability … for some or all of a response action’ to mean ‘settled an environmental liability that might have been actionable under CERCLA’ would stretch the statute beyond Congress’ actual language.” The court thus held that, for an action to be considered a CERCLA response to toll the statute of limitations, CERCLA-specific liability must have been found.

The holding allows the case against the US to proceed.

Article: Supreme Court allows case against U.S. for causing toxic waste pollution in Guam


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

(UN General Assembly, 1948) The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: 1. All human beings are free and equal 2. No discrimination 3. Right to life 4. No slavery 5. No torture and inhuman treatment 6. Same right to use law 7. Equal before the law 8. Right to be treated fair by court 9. No unfair detainment 10. Right to trial 11. Innocent until proved guilty 12. Right to privacy 13. Freedom to movement and residence 14. Right to asylum 15. Right to nationality 16. Rights to marry and have family 17. Right to own things 18. Freedom of thought and religion 19. Freedom of opinion and expression 20. Right to assemble 21. Right to democracy 22. Right to social security 23. Right to work 24. Right to rest and holiday 25. Right of social service 26. Right to education 27. Right of cultural and art 28. Freedom around the world 29. Subject to law 30. Human rights can’t be taken away