Menu Close

EU court advisor: Hungary anti-migrant laws violate EU Law

The Advocate General of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) found Thursday that Hungary’s criminalization of activities aimed at helping migrants who did not fulfil its national criteria for the grant of asylum violated EU law.

The opinion comes in response to a series of laws, more popularly known as “Stop Soros laws,” passed by the Hungarian Parliament in 2018, which had amended Hungary’s asylum laws and made the conditions for accessing international protection procedures and the conditions for carrying on activities intended to aid migrants for such international protection more difficult. More concretely, the amendments first introduced a new ground for inadmissibility for applications for international protection. It also criminalized activities intended to enable migrants to start the international protection procedure and further laid down restrictions on persons prosecuted or punished for such an offense.

In response to the new laws, the European Commission had brought the case before the ECJ as part of an infringement procedure it launched against Hungary in 2018 over its non-compliance with asylum law.

In his opinion, Advocate General Athanasios Rantos first recalled that the ECJ, in a 2020 ruling had already considered the introduction of a new ground of inadmissibility for international protection as unlawful. He further held that the subsequent provisions criminalizing assistance for applicants for international protection “constitutes an unjustified obstacle to the exercise of the rights guaranteed by the EU legislation concerning assistance for applicants for international protection and, accordingly, constitutes a failure to fulfill the obligations under that legislation.”

While the advocate general’s opinions are not binding on the ECJ, their rulings are often followed by the court in its subsequent judgment.

Article: EU court advisor: Hungary anti-migrant laws violate EU Law


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

(UN General Assembly, 1948) The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: 1. All human beings are free and equal 2. No discrimination 3. Right to life 4. No slavery 5. No torture and inhuman treatment 6. Same right to use law 7. Equal before the law 8. Right to be treated fair by court 9. No unfair detainment 10. Right to trial 11. Innocent until proved guilty 12. Right to privacy 13. Freedom to movement and residence 14. Right to asylum 15. Right to nationality 16. Rights to marry and have family 17. Right to own things 18. Freedom of thought and religion 19. Freedom of opinion and expression 20. Right to assemble 21. Right to democracy 22. Right to social security 23. Right to work 24. Right to rest and holiday 25. Right of social service 26. Right to education 27. Right of cultural and art 28. Freedom around the world 29. Subject to law 30. Human rights can’t be taken away