Menu Close

Over a dozen think tanks call for end of ‘digital censorship’ in India

New Delhi: More than a dozen privacy and digital think tanks from across the world have banded together to publish an open letter calling for the end of ‘digital censorship’ in India.

The letter, signed by 14 not-for-profits and published on Friday, called upon the government to suspend the implementation of India’s new IT rules, which came into effect last month. These include organisations like Electronics Frontier Foundation, Access Now, Article 19, Human Rights Watch, Internet Sans Frontières and Internet Society.

The letter asked the government to make public its blocking orders for websites and social media accounts along with reasons for the blocking. India should commit to not using these orders, and rule-making powers, to curtail the rights to free speech, access to information and privacy, it urged.

There are “troubling indicators that the Indian Government, which has already been criticised for silencing protests, criminalising dissent, and blocking access to the internet, will use the expanded powers under the new intermediary rules…to restrict online content, and chill free expression and access to information,” according to the letter.

ET has reviewed a copy of the letter.

The Association for Progressive Communications, Centre for Democracy and Technology, CIVICUS: World Alliance for Citizen Participation, Dangerous Speech Project, International Commission of Jurists, Mnemonic, OpenNet and Reporters Without Borders, are its other signatories.

India notified the guidelines in February and gave those social media platforms with over 5 million users in the country three months to comply. The rules, which apply to companies such as Facebook, WhatsApp and Twitter, came into effect on May 25. It mandates online platforms to have a physical office in India, appoint key personnel to handle user grievances and take down notices from the government, along with giving them a timeline of 24 hours to remove content and 72 hours to respond with information. Platforms with end-to-end encryption like WhatsApp are required to trace the origin of messages if the investigative agencies require them to.

WhatsApp has challenged the traceability mandate in Delhi High Court, while Google has asked the courts to exempt its search engine from being classified as a significant social media intermediary.

“Web censorship and user data orders from the Government of India are not issued under judicial or independent administrative process; instead, they come from the unilateral dictates of executive authorities. Indian Government authorities have refused to publish any of the orders they are issuing to technology firms, asserting a broad claim of secrecy, and denying requests under India’s Right to Information Act,” it said.

The letter also highlighted that the regulatory framework for digital news media also grants the government an “unprecedented, impermissible and unconstitutional” level of control over online news. “The rules are beyond the scope of what the executive is authorised to do under current law,” it said.

The liabilities on employees of the platforms, in case of non-compliance, serve to intimidate intermediaries and their employees into over-complying with overbroad mandates, to the detriment of users’ rights, the letter said.

It called upon technology companies and internet platforms operating in India to “implement effective measures to protect privacy, free expression and security, and push back on overbroad, unlawful requests and regulatory mandates.”

Article: Over a dozen think tanks call for end of ‘digital censorship’ in India

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

(UN General Assembly, 1948) The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: 1. All human beings are free and equal 2. No discrimination 3. Right to life 4. No slavery 5. No torture and inhuman treatment 6. Same right to use law 7. Equal before the law 8. Right to be treated fair by court 9. No unfair detainment 10. Right to trial 11. Innocent until proved guilty 12. Right to privacy 13. Freedom to movement and residence 14. Right to asylum 15. Right to nationality 16. Rights to marry and have family 17. Right to own things 18. Freedom of thought and religion 19. Freedom of opinion and expression 20. Right to assemble 21. Right to democracy 22. Right to social security 23. Right to work 24. Right to rest and holiday 25. Right of social service 26. Right to education 27. Right of cultural and art 28. Freedom around the world 29. Subject to law 30. Human rights can’t be taken away